The projected landmark moment for the Muhos municipality seems to have come early. Just days after Google’s announcement, the Finnish Association for Nature Conservation made public their suspicions of illegal logging on both construction sites. The Finnish outlet Yle reported: “Large-scale forest work began in the areas months ago, even though the environmental impact assessment of the projects is still ongoing.” Simultaneously, the Finnish Supervisory Agency LVV had started investigating the incidents.
International attention turned to the towns in Finland when the agency released two documents asking Tuike to halt all preparatory work on both data center sites. LVV writes that the company had failed to follow standard Finnish environmental procedures:
If much of the site is already cleared before the assessment is finished, alternatives or harm prevention can no longer happen. The assessment loses its purpose. In addition, a project can’t be split into stages for early steps to escape an assessment, LVV writes citing an EU Court of Justice ruling. A third reason the agency names is the extent of Tuike’s “preparatory work”. LVV argues that the works are already big enough to need an assessment on their own.
First, Tuike leaned on the municipalities supposedly allowing the company to begin the preparations for their construction sites. Later, the company backed down and Google’s Finland Country Director, Antti Järvinen, apologised for “extensive forest clearances at the company’s data centre sites in Muhos and Kajaani.”
Early consequences
At the Muhos site alone, more than 250,000 trees were felled, the Guardian reports. Another 150,000 were cut in the southern site in Kajaani. Wolves were displaced by the clearings and entered the village, the Guardian quoted a resident as saying.
Simultaneously, opposition has formed against the data center plans and the lack of suitable legislation to protect nature and people in Finland from such projects. A citizens’ initiative aims to regulate data centres and subject their development to stricter reviews. 97,000 people have signed the petition.
Tuike has put construction preparations on hold for now. A spokesperson told the Guardian: “We have operated in Finland for 15 years and have always worked to meet or exceed zoning, environmental, health and safety requirements. After receiving the LVV letters on 6 October, we stopped preparatory works at Muhos and Kajaani and have submitted a formal response to LVV confirming this.”
The spokesperson added that Tuike would fully comply with LVV’s requests and is looking forward to “maintaining an active, open dialogue with all authorities to strengthen our partnership with Finland and local organisations.”
Otter News and Vertical52
Vertical52 is co-publishing this story with the newly founded, climate- and environment-focused newsroom Otter News. Anyone who wishes to enable investigative environmental and climate reporting can support Otter News by becoming a member. Only if a total of 3,000 people become “Otters” by mid-January will Daniel Drepper’s editorial team be able to get started in 2027. We at Vertical52 are looking forward to many more future collaborations and joint investigations.